Major Problem with cPanel Hotlink Protection and htaccess

There is a major problem with the “Hotlink Protection” feature of cPanel. To summarize the issue, allow me to quote a recent email sent to a completely unresponsive tech support department:

…The problem is that if I try to include any rewrite rules for permalinks, hotlinking, or blocking spambots, cPanel automatically enables its “Hotlink Protection” feature. And, even worse, it automatically adds every URL from every rewrite rule (even the ones for blocking spambots) to its “auto-discovered” list of URL’s for which image access is allowed.

This means that every spammer that I am trying to block now has access to my images! If I try to remove the spammers directly from the “allow-image-access” list, the associated rewrite rules are automatically removed from my htaccess file, thus giving spammers full access to my entire site (instead of just access to images).

So, it is indeed the case that I can’t add any rewrite rules to my site’s root htaccess file without cPanel automatically assuming that every URL on the page is related to hotlinking and subsequently adding them all to the “allow-image-access” list…

[ Image: Train Wreck ] In other words, cPanel screws up htaccess rewrite rules via its “Hotlink Protection” feature. More specifically, spammers and robots that are denied site access via root-htaccess rewrite rules are automatically listed in the “allow access to images” field of the Hotlink Protection panel. Not good. Even worse, disabling Hotlink Protection automatically removes every rewrite rule from the htaccess file. Such bizarre functionality forces the user to choose between complete hotlink protection and other essential features such as pretty permalinks or spam blocking. Pretty sucky if you ask us. Nonetheless, here is a concise summary of the problem with the cPanel Hotlink Protection (cHP) feature:

  1. cHP enables itself when any rewrite rules are added to root .htaccess
  2. cHP includes every URL associated with such rewrite rules in its list of allowed sites
  3. cHP removes all rewrite rules from .htaccess when it’s manually disabled
  4. cHP deletes rewrite rules associated with any URL that is selectively removed from its whitelist

Therefore, based on the automatically perpetuated behavior of cHP, it appears impossible to enjoy htaccess hotlink protection along with any other rewrite-rule functionality. For example, you could employ hotlink protection but not WordPress permalinks. Likewise, to block spammers and scrapers, you would have to sacrifice hotlink protection. With cHP, it’s one or the other — you simply can’t have both. Very frustrating!